Wisconsin Senate bill would expand indoor smoking ban to vapor products and marijuanaSubmitted: 06/03/2019
Story By Stephen Goin

Wisconsin Senate bill would expand indoor smoking ban to vapor products and marijuana
NORTHWOODS - Taking a smoke break usually means going outside to have a cigarette. In Wisconsin, people don't have a choice.

In 2009, the state assembly passed a law that made smoking tobacco products illegal in public places, at work or in any enclosed space with two or more "substantial" walls. A bipartisan group of state lawmakers introduced a bill last week to add vapor products and marijuana to that ban.

Sen. Andrè Jaque (R-DePere) and Sen. Fred Risser (D-Madison), the authors of Senate Bill 245, say health risks linked to vaping, like lung and cardiovascular diseases, inspired the legislation.

A decade after the original smoke-free air law, some people still look back fondly at the days when smoking was allowed indoors. Rob Swearingen, the owner of The Al-Gen Dinner Club in Rhinelander, jokes that the air purifiers still installed over the bar at his restaurant are antiques even though they were used just ten years ago.

"Smoking … it was just part of a lifestyle back then," said Swearingen.

When the state of Wisconsin passed the indoor smoking ban, Swearingen's restaurant was already phasing it out successfully. The Al-Gen went from having a separate smoking and non-smoking dining section to only allowing smoking where alcohol was sold separately from food.

"I think that society kind of just dictated that smoking was on the downturn," said Swearingen.

But the Former Tavern League president, now a Republican state assemblyman, says other businesses, like standalone bars, didn't fare so well.

"Those places were impacted quite negatively, because that customer base [sic] drinking and smoking went together," said Swearingen.

Tom Simic, owner of Northern Lights Vapor in Tomahawk, says the proposed ban is a step too far.

"I think more than anything it amounts to once again governmental overreach," said Simic.

He says the ban would be hard to enforce because e-cigs are easy to conceal and that the reported health risks are exaggerated.

"If they would look up some of the reputable studies out there I think they'd find it to be a bit different," said Simic.

He believes a ban on vaping indoors should be at the discretion of business owners. Swearingen agrees, adding that the expanded ban could be a further hit to businesses in his district. 

"To force the tavern around the corner to now go vape free doesn't seem like the right way to head," said Swearingen.

Simic says the bill won't stop his business, though. He's making sure his hard work doesn't go up in smoke, or in this case, vapor.

"We have helped in the last five years somewhere between 1,000 and 1,200 hundred people quit [smoking]," said Simic. "I think that's a good service for the community don't you?"

SB 245 was introduced and referred to the committee on Government Operations, Technology and Consumer Protection.

Another bill targeting vapor products was introduced in March by many of the same authors and cosponsors of SB 245. SB 73 would prohibit the sale of vapor products to minors. 

Text Size: + Increase | Decrease -
| Print Story | Email Story
Sponsored in part by HodagSports.com


MADISON - The Wisconsin Elections Commission voted Wednesday to mail absentee ballot applications to most voters in the battleground state ahead of November's presidential election.

+ Read More

WASHINGTON - An estimated 2.1 million Americans applied for unemployment benefits last week despite the gradual reopening of businesses around the country, bringing the running total since the coronavirus shutdowns took hold in mid-March to about 41 million, the government said Thursday.

+ Read More

WEST ALLIS - The Wisconsin State Fair was canceled Thursday due to the coronavirus pandemic, marking the first time since 1945 that the 169-year-old annual tradition will not take place.

+ Read More

WASHINGTON - President Donald Trump is escalating his war on social media companies, preparing to sign an executive order Thursday challenging the liability protections that have served as a bedrock for unfettered speech on the internet.

+ Read More

RHINELANDER - The Wisconsin State fair traditionally focuses on animals, family activities, music and more. The planning committee made it clear that their main focus this year is safety. 

+ Read More

- A shift to mail voting is increasing the chances that Americans will not know the winner of November's presidential race on election night, a scenario that is fueling worries about whether President Donald Trump will use the delay to sow doubts about the results.

+ Read More

MINNEAPOLIS - Violent protests over the death of a black man in police custody rocked a Minneapolis neighborhood for a second straight night as angry crowds looted stores, set fires and left a path of damage that stretched for miles. The mayor asked the governor to activate the National Guard.

The protests that began late Wednesday and stretched into Thursday morning were the most destructive yet since the death of George Floyd, who was seen on video gasping for breath during an arrest in which an officer kneeled on his neck for almost eight minutes. In the footage, Floyd pleads that he cannot breathe and slowly stops talking and moving.

+ Read More
+ More General News