Loading
Search
NEWS STORIES

Judge looks at evidence during motion hearing in Mendez murder caseSubmitted: 12/13/2018
Story By Rose McBride

Judge looks at evidence during motion hearing in Mendez murder case
ONEIDA COUNTY - Thursday morning, Oneida County District Attorney Michael Schiek argued an affair with a 15-year-old girl gave Robin Mendez motive to murder his wife, Barbara Mendez, in 1982. 

"There was the potential for that information and that affair to be released to other people in the community even the victim, Barbara," said Schiek. 

But Thursday Mendez's attorney argued the affair should not be a part of that evidence. Peter Prusinski said the affair began in the summer of 1981 and ended in the fall of 1982. Nothing stopped it from happening, even the murder.


"If this was relevant to motive, we could expect a change in behavior in the status of the affair. The affair was going on before and after the death of Barbara Mendez," said Prusinski. 

Judge Jill Falstad ultimately decided to allow the affair as evidence because it would provide intent for Mendez. 

This afternoon, lawyers and Judge Falstad met again, this time to determine whether D.A. Schiek can call a forensic expert as a witness in trial. Christopher Robinson, a private forensic consultant and expert in crime scene reconstruction, appeared via video. 

He used clay molds to show that Barbara's injuries were consistent with a hit to the head with a pry bar, which is often used in upholstery. That's the type of business Mendez's family owned. 

But Mendez's lawyer argued that this type of science is not precise enough and Robinson's testimony should not be accepted. 

"I do not believe there are sufficient facts and data that he used in his experimentation today to establish what he is testifying to and that the testimony is a product of reliable principles and methods," said Prusinski.

Judge Falstad heard both arguments, and well as questioning of Robinson, and will make a decision after reviewing all materials. 


Text Size: + Increase | Decrease -
| Print Story | Email Story
Sponsored in part by HodagSports.com





 IN OTHER NEWS

RHINELANDER - Farmers and ranchers who have been financially hurt by the coronavirus have the opportunity to get aid from the federal government starting today (Tuesday).

Applications for the USDA's "Coronavirus Food Assistance Program" will be accepted through Aug. 28.

+ Read More

FOX LAKE, WI - A physical therapist nurse on staff at Fox Lake Correctional Institution (FLCI) has tested positive for COVID-19.

At 8 am count this morning several residents who had been in contact with her were moved to the segregation unit for quarantine.

+ Read More

MADISON - The Wisconsin Supreme Court is allowing circuit courts to resume in-person hearings and jury trials if they can come up with plans to protect participants and observers from the coronavirus.

The high court suspended in-person hearings and jury trials in March, ordering judges to move trials to a date after May 22.

+ Read More

- We hear a lot of advisory terms involving weather every now and again:  Winter Weather Advisory; Flood Advisory;  Small Craft Advisory.The National Weather Service is worried that people don't always know how to interpret or understand these phrases, so they're proposing an idea to help simplify things.

+ Read More

ST. GERMAIN - Images of Highway 51 clogged with tourists emerged over the Memorial Day weekend.

The seasonal tourist traffic presents both an opportunity and a challenge for local businesses.

St. Germain Chamber of Commerce director Penny Strom says most businesses in Vilas County are ready for the crowds.

Neither tourists or businesses have any restrictions placed upon them by the state, but are encouraged to follow local guidelines.

Strom observed that tourists were mostly respectful toward the locals over the weekend.

+ Read More

JANESVILLE, WI - Authorities say two people have been hurt, including one with serious injuries, after a house exploded in Janesville.

Fire Department Battalion Chief Ron Bomkamp says that one tenant had smelled gas for a while and when another tenant lit a cigarette, the home exploded Monday night.

Firefighters responded about 9:15 p.m. after neighbors reported the duplex was on fire.

+ Read More

ONEIDA COUNTY - Oneida County Health Department (OCHD) has received notification an eighth person in Oneida County has been diagnosed with novel coronavirus infection (COVID-19).

The individual is in their 30's and has no history of travel and no known contact with someone who has previously tested positive for COVID-19. The individual was tested at one of the Wisconsin National Guard Community Testing events and has been self-isolating.

County health officials are working to determine how the individual may have become infected and are contacting others with whom the person with the positive result had close contact with.



+ Read More
+ More General News
Search: