Loading
Search
TOP STORY

Judge looks at evidence during motion hearing in Mendez murder caseSubmitted: 12/13/2018

Play Video
ONEIDA COUNTY - Thursday morning, Oneida County District Attorney Michael Schiek argued an affair with a 15-year-old girl gave Robin Mendez motive to murder his wife, Barbara Mendez, in 1982. 

"There was the potential for that information and that affair to be released to other people in the community even the victim, Barbara," said Schiek. 

But Thursday Mendez's attorney argued the affair should not be a part of that evidence. Peter Prusinski said the affair began in the summer of 1981 and ended in the fall of 1982. Nothing stopped it from happening, even the murder.


"If this was relevant to motive, we could expect a change in behavior in the status of the affair. The affair was going on before and after the death of Barbara Mendez," said Prusinski. 

Judge Jill Falstad ultimately decided to allow the affair as evidence because it would provide intent for Mendez. 

This afternoon, lawyers and Judge Falstad met again, this time to determine whether D.A. Schiek can call a forensic expert as a witness in trial. Christopher Robinson, a private forensic consultant and expert in crime scene reconstruction, appeared via video. 

He used clay molds to show that Barbara's injuries were consistent with a hit to the head with a pry bar, which is often used in upholstery. That's the type of business Mendez's family owned. 

But Mendez's lawyer argued that this type of science is not precise enough and Robinson's testimony should not be accepted. 

"I do not believe there are sufficient facts and data that he used in his experimentation today to establish what he is testifying to and that the testimony is a product of reliable principles and methods," said Prusinski.

Judge Falstad heard both arguments, and well as questioning of Robinson, and will make a decision after reviewing all materials. 


Story By: Rose McBride

Text Size: + Increase | Decrease -
 Print Story Print Story | Email Story Email Story






 LOCAL NEWS

Play Video

PLOVER - Last February, the condition of a pit bull named Darcy helped force a dog kennel seizure by Oneida County Sheriff's deputies, an arrest of their owner, and the stripping of her dog license.

A Rhinelander veterinarian found Darcy was the victim of severe neglect at It Matters to One Animal Rescue in Sugar Camp, and soon after, 38 other dogs were taken from the property.

It took Darcy a year to find a new home while staying at the humane society. But now, Darcy is living happily in Portage County.

"She needs to live a quiet, retired, peaceful life," said Darcy's new owner, Vanessa DeWalt.

+ Read More

Play Video

LAND O' LAKES - People passing by Land O'Lakes over the last year may notice some changes in town. Namely, the new businesses starting up.

Members of the Vilas County Economic Development Corporation (VCEDC) and Land O' Lakes Chamber of Commerce say there isn't any one particular reason for the recent business boom in Land O' Lakes. But rather that the community as a whole working together and preparing for these opportunities is what's paying off. 

+ Read More

Play Video

RHINELANDER - Sixth grader Marcus Anderson enjoys class projects. He also likes drawing, playing outside, and hanging with his dog. But there's one other thing he likes the most.

"Helping out classmates," Anderson said.

Anderson's teachers at James Williams Middle School in Rhinelander said he's a helpful student.

So helpful, they nominated him for a special contest called 95.5 Hero of the Week.

H&R Block and WIFC radio in Wausau run the contest. They select a nominated student as their Hero of the Week and the student is then recognized and given a trophy.

+ Read More

Play Video

EAGLE RIVER - Newswatch 12 spoke with a man who got two scam calls from someone pretending to be an Eagle River police officer and another pretending to be a firefighter.

Both scam calls asked for donations.

Eagle River Fire Chief Michael Anderson says he thinks the caller is a local because the department is taking donations for a second station, but not over the phone.

+ Read More

Play Video

TOMAHAWK - Some police officers deal with drugs on a daily basis.

A new report shows that the drug Fentanyl is on the rise now, and it's the number one cause of drug overdoses.

This drug not only puts the abuser's life on the line but the officers' lives too.

Tomahawk police officer Matt Gorell said the drug is extremely dangerous.

If officers come into contact with it by breathing it in or even touching it, they could die in a short period of time.

+ Read More

Play Video

RHINELANDER - Around 9:30 Wednesday morning police and fire crews responded to a semi versus car accident.

The crash happened on Highway 47 near Birch Lane in Rhinelander, just across the street from the Shell gas station.

The driver of the car was taken to a hospital with non-life threatening injuries after pulling out in-front of the semi.

The truck driver was unharmed.
Oneida County Sheriff's Department says a citation is possible.

+ Read More

Play Video

RHINELANDER - The sounds of Christmas echoed through the halls of the Oneida County Courthouse Wednesday.

"It was a bit nerve racking," said seventh grader Kyleah Hartman.

Hartman is part of the James Williams Middle School audition group called Show Stars.

She says they've been preparing for this gig since the beginning of October.

"We've been practicing every Monday after school," said Hartman.

County Clerk Tracy Hartman invited the group to the courthouse for the first time.

+ Read More
+ More Local News
Search: 








Click Here