Loading
Search
NEWS STORIES

County committee 'erroneous' in hospital rejection, Marshfield Clinic says in appealSubmitted: 08/16/2017
County committee 'erroneous' in hospital rejection, Marshfield Clinic says in appeal
Ben Meyer
Ben Meyer
Managing Editor / Senior Reporter
bmeyer@wjfw.com

RHINELANDER - Marshfield Clinic calls Oneida County's rejection of a Minocqua hospital an "erroneous application of the law."

Marshfield Clinic cites 14 court decisions from across the country in its appeal of the Planning Committee's June vote to deny a conditional use permit (CUP).


The Clinic wants to build a 12-bed hospital within a half-mile of Howard Young hospital in Woodruff. The hospital would be adjacent to its current outpatient facility and cost more than $30 million to build.

In June, the Oneida County Planning and Development Committee voted 3-2 to deny a permit to build. The rejection came after three of the five supervisors on the committee said Marshfield Clinic didn't meet a condition reading, "The establishment, maintenance or operation of the conditional use will not be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety, morals, comfort or general welfare."

In its appeal, the Clinic says the county committee incorrectly considered potential competition with Howard Young in the denial.

"Indeed, it is difficult to envision any situation in which a hospital could be detrimental to or endanger health, safety or welfare, and no such evidence was presented here," wrote Daniel Kirschnik, Marshfield Clinic's Assistant General Counsel, in the appeal. "Instead, the denial was based solely on the uncorroborated concerns that a second hospital in the Town would compete with the existing Howard Young Medical Center."

The appeal will go before Oneida County's Board of Adjustment, which has power to overturn the Planning and Development Committee's decision.

"The Planning Committee's decision to deny the CUP was based solely on concerns about competition with the existing Howard Young Medical Center," Kirschnik wrote. "As the foregoing case law establishes, this is an improper basis upon which to deny a CUP application. In the exercise of its zoning authority, the Planning Committee does not have the power to regulate competition or establish health care policy."

The Board of Adjustment will select a date to consider Marshfield Clinic's appeal at its Thursday meeting.

Text Size: + Increase | Decrease -
| Print Story | Email Story
Sponsored in part by HodagSports.com





 IN OTHER NEWS

ST. GERMAIN - After your big Thanksgiving meal later this week, you might be looking for a way to get active.

St. Germain will be hosting its holiday light parade and Jingle Bell 3K Race this Saturday.

People will pull out their lawn chairs and wool blankets to watch floats take over downtown.

The St. Germain A-T-V club will also be collecting food along the parade route for the Vilas County Food Pantry.

"St. Germain has always had the tradition of the town tree lighting and caroling and stuff like that. We just amped it up and taken it one step further. It is really neat to be a part of and kick off the Christmas season," says special events coordinator Judy Jurries.

You can still register for the Jingle Bell 3K Race.



+ Read More

Play Video

GREEN BAY - One man who grew up in Tomahawk is now in charge of keeping thousands of fans safe at Lambeau Field.

For a noon kickoff game most Packer fans start preparing a few hours before.

"It's actually a full weekend for me it'll start Friday night into Saturday," said Green Bay Police Department Operations Commander Paul Ebel.

Ebel is the Operations Commander for the Green Bay Police Department and needs a 48 hour head start to cover all his responsibilities.

" If something does happen at the stadium it's one of those things when they turn around and say okay what do we do and that's my role," said Ebel.

Ebel's is in constant communication with departments like the FBI and SWAT team during home games while he patrols with odor detecting dogs.

" It's a little bit more stressful than people think. I also look at world events, what's going on in the world and how we're postured for security," said Ebel.

Since starting his position about four years ago.

Recent attacks around the world changed how Ebel views safety at Lambeau Field.

"There are standards on conduct the NFL has. If you're rude and obnoxious to fans inside the stadium you'll be asked to leave," said Ebel.

+ Read More

MADISON (AP) - Local governments are considering putting their own mining regulations in place as Gov. Scott Walker prepares to lift Wisconsin's nearly 20-year ban on gold and silver mining.

Walker voted for the moratorium when he was in the state Assembly but is expected to sign a GOP bill that lifts the prohibition. The bill comes as Aquila Resources Inc. is considering potential mining sites in Taylor and Marathon counties.


+ Read More

WISCONSIN - Around 9:12 a.m. on Saturday emergency responders assisted a 49-year-old Crandon man who accidentally shot himself while hunting in Armstrong Creek, according to DNR Safety Specialist Warden Mark Little.

Little said the man saw a deer while sitting in his truck. He went to grab his rifle, and as he was manipulating the gun it went off. A bullet went through the man's upper right leg and lower left leg, exiting out the driver-side door.

+ Read More

RHINELANDER - You can find movies, popcorn and candy at Rouman Cinema in Rhinelander.

But Sunday, the theatre lobby was filled with turkeys, corn and potatoes.

Owner of the cinema, George Rouman says he has been donating Thanksgiving meals to those in need since 1995.

Goldie Kalas was lucky enough Sunday to receive the 5,000th meal donated by the cinema since it started 22 years ago.

+ Read More

Play Video

EAGLE RIVER - For people who don't like to hunt, an event held tonight gave them another option. The first ever Widow's Wine Walk took place in downtown Eagle River.

Women could sample up to 15 of 24 different wines at 12 participating businesses. Along with the wine tastings, women who paid the $20 ticket also got coupons for each shop.

+ Read More

Play Video

NORTHWOODS - "We got up before daylight and went out in the woods," said Sierra Endel, who is from Hazelhurst. 

Hunters all across the Northwoods were ready to go for the start this year's gun deer hunt.

"Opening day has been okay, we got two bucks on the pole right now so it's a good start," said Justin Pitlik from Eagle River. 

+ Read More
+ More General News
Search: 





Click Here