Loading
Search
NEWS STORIES

Family seeks answers after a 911 call leads to confusionSubmitted: 04/10/2017
Dakota Sherek
Dakota Sherek
Reporter/Anchor
dsherek@wjfw.com

Family seeks answers after a 911 call leads to confusion
RHINELANDER - A bomb squad team, special responders, and dozens of law enforcement officers filled a Rhinelander neighborhood last Friday for what they thought was a potentially violent situation. 

The hours-long ordeal eventually ended with the discovery that it was simply a medical emergency.


"Total shock as to how this all played out and how they [law enforcement] got this information that was not true," said Shannon Smith, daughter of the 911 caller.

Thomas Smith was detained by law enforcement after he called 911 for a medical emergency.

"He point blank was trying to get help and it was taken way too far, and now my dad is in the hospital," said Shannon.

He got medical help, but the family says police wounded him, too.

"My dad does have cuts, scrapes on his head, a bump on his head, cut-up knees," said Alan Smith, Thomas Smith's son.

Sixty-five-year-old Smith has Parkinson's disease, and his family says he cannot physically speak. So when Smith called 911, the dispatcher had to use a special technique to communicate with him.

911 operators can prompt callers to respond through button pushes. 

"It's not been used in… forever," said Oneida County Sheriff's Office Capt. Terri Hook.

When Smith indicated that he needed both the police and an ambulance, the dispatcher asked follow-up questions throughout the 56-minute call. 

Smith's responses led law enforcement to believe Smith was being held hostage by a man with guns and explosives.

Smith's family doesn't buy it.

"When a person cannot communicate, and he's short of breath, you're going to press every button on the phone to get help," said Alan.

The dispatch call ended abruptly. So when Smith exited his home, the Oneida County Special Response team detained him.

The family says Smith was treated roughly.

"He did say he was forced down, he was slammed to the ground," said Alan.

Hook says Smith was not following directions, so Smith was then "decentralized." 

"We acted on the information that we had," Hook said. "We couldn't have acted any other way."

The family says Smith will be OK, but the experience has taken a toll on him.

"He is just really shaken up, he's very upset, a lot of different emotions going on with my family," said Shannon.

Meanwhile, Hook says law enforcement did what they needed to do.

"We needed to keep the community safe as well as our officers safe, and we just did the best we could with the information that we had," said Hook. 

The family thinks the situation should have been handled differently.

"I'm his voice, and I'm going to make sure that this doesn't happen again to anybody else," said Alan.

WJFW spoke with Smith's son on Monday. He said Smith would most likely be in the hospital for a couple more days.




Text Size: + Increase | Decrease -
| Print Story | Email Story
Sponsored in part by HodagSports.com





 IN OTHER NEWS

VILAS COUNTY - Many people love sightseeing on two wheels throughout the Northwoods.

Now, you can get a prize for doing it.

"Bike the Heart" encourages riders to explore the different communities along the Heart of Vilas County Trail.

The trail is more than 45 miles of paved path that connects Boulder Junction, Sayner, St. Germain and Manitowish Waters.

The goal of "Bike the Heart" is to stop at each Chamber of Commerce with a "pass card" to get a stamp.

You have until September to collect four stamps and send it in to one of the chambers to be entered for a prize worth more than $100.

"Bringing the bicyclists to this area is astronomical. We have inquiries from the entire Midwest and even the outlying states of California and New York," says executive director Penny Wiesmann of St. Germain Chamber of Commerce.

Mile markers and "fix-it" stations are the newest additions to the Heart of Vilas County Trail.

The stations have tools attached to the sides to help you make a quick fix on your bike.

"We're just really excited that people can come up and ride up the entire length of the trail, or if they want to take up some smaller portions they can do that to," says executive director Theresa Smith of Boulder Junction Chamber of Commerce.



+ Read More
What We're Working OnSubmitted: 05/23/2017

- Tonight on Newswatch 12:

We'll show you a training course for Taylor County deputies and courthouse staff on how to respond with and active shooter in the courthouse.

We'll take you live to Shepard Park in Rhinelander, the site some residents hope will have sections set aside for a dog park. Monday the Parks committed approved the proposal.

And a Nicolet College club provides a safe space for lesbian, gay, bi-sexual and transgender students and allies to discuss personal issues. Now they want to get a group started outside the campus. We talk to a member of the Rainbow Hodags Club about his experiences with the group.

We'll bring you the details on these stories and more tonight on Newswatch 12 - news from where you live.

+ Read More

MINOCQUA - In 2006, more than 40,000 pets died in fires due to smoke inhalation. 

That number has gone down, in large part, thanks to oxygen masks designed for animals. 

The Minocqua Fire Department got its own set of pet oxygen masks Tuesday.

+ Read More

RHINELANDER - Most people stop by Rhinelander's Chamber of Commerce to get their picture with the giant Hodag out front. Visitors to the chamber can also stock up on Rhinelander trinkets and gear.

Now, the chamber has decided to downsize its store in order to let someone else set up shop. 

+ Read More

MADISON - The Legislature's budget committee has decided to put off votes on the University of Wisconsin System budget because Senate Republicans can't agree on what to do about tuition rates.

Gov. Scott Walker's budget calls for cutting tuition by 5 percent and giving the system $35 million to offset the lost revenue. It also would give the system $42.5 million in additional state aid. Campuses that do better on new performance standards would get bigger chunks of the funding.

+ Read More

Play Video

MERRILL - People who lost their homes in last week's tornado will get state help, but likely no federal dollars to rebuild.

Initial estimates from the Barron County Sheriff's Office put the damage from last week's tornado at $10 million.

+ Read More

Play Video

RHINELANDER - Stepping onto a boat and casting a line doesn't come easy for some people.

The Northwoods "Let's Go Fishing" pontoon helps veterans, seniors, the disabled get on the lake for a day of fun.

The Northwoods chapter needs volunteer captains and mates to keep the rides running.

+ Read More
+ More General News
Search: 





Click Here